CheeseScience.net: The Guardian and Cheese Problems...

The Guardian and Cheese Problems...

Cheese Problems Solved today (Tuesday February 27) got a light-hearted mention from Hugh Muir, diarist (but obviously not dairyist!) of the UK's Guardian newspaper (p. 29 of the tabloid edition):

"Finally", he writes, "the thirst for knowledge draws us to Bookseller magazine and the Oddest Book Title of the Year compeitition. The shortlist bears testimony to the quality on display this year. Cheese Problems Solved is an obvious contender, as is You Want Closure in Your Relationship, Start with your Legs. People Who Mattered in Southend, From King Canute to Dr Feelgood, means the historical end is catered for. But can anything beat I Was Tortured by the Pygmy Love Queen. Love, laughs and drama, and that's just the cover."

I never thought the title funny, but now that I think of it...

Update

Apparently, the poll for oddest book title of the year is open here. Seeing some of the other titles, I don't think I have a hope! Mind you, the 5 min slot this evening on BBC Radio 2's Chris Evans Show might help (apparently heard by 5 million British people stuck in traffic on the M25 while on their way home from work)...

www.cheesescience.net

Cheese Science

Introduction. Cheese is the generic name for a group of fermented milk-based food products produced worldwide in a wide range of flavours and forms. Although there is no reliable estimate of the number of cheese varieties produced throughout the world, well over 1000 named varieties are recognized. Cheese is the quintessential convenience food; indeed, it has been said that there is a cheese for every taste preference and a taste preference for every cheese. Cheese manufacture, which dates from 6000-7000 BC, is essentially a method for preserving the nutritive value of milk through fermentation, removal of moisture and addition of salt.

Cheese is the most diverse group of dairy products and is arguably the most academically interesting and scientifically challenging. Unlike many other foods, which are relatively biologically and physically stable, cheeses are biologically and biochemically dynamic and hence are unstable. Cheesemakers often say that their product is “alive”; although this is obviously literally incorrect, this feeling contains a grain of truth, since cheese is a bacterial ecosystem and changes considerably during maturation due to a series of biochemical transformations. If these changes are balanced, they lead to the production of a very large number of flavour compounds and thus the highly desirable aromas and flavours of different cheeses. It is fascinating that such a wide range of flavours can be produced from the basic ingredients of cheese which are milk, starter cultures, salt and often rennet. A wide range of scientific disciplines are applied to cheese: biochemistry, microbiology, enzymology, molecular genetics, flavour chemistry and rheology (the science of the flow and deformation of matter). Although cheesemaking is an ancient art, modern industrial cheese production relies heavily on the application of these branches of science to ensure a consistently high quality product. Cheesemaking is amongst the world’s largest uses of industrial enzymes, its fermentation is more complicated than many other industrial fermentations (e.g., in the pharmaceutical industry) and the maturation of cheese is biochemically very dynamic. Indeed, if cheese was invented today, it would be hailed as a triumph of biotechnology!

Classification of cheese. The many varieties of cheese may be classified into a few families depending on the way in which the milk is coagulated. The majority of cheeses are coagulated by rennet, where the milk is converted to a gel by the action of an enzyme. Rennet-coagulated cheeses include the majority of major international varieties (e.g., Cheddar, Gouda, Mozzarella, Swiss, Blue, Camembert). The milk for a second family of cheese varieties is coagulated by acidification. Acid-coagulated varieties, including Cottage cheese and Quark, differ from yogurt (which is essentially acid-gelled milk) by the fact that some moisture is removed in the form of whey whereas yogurt has nearly the same moisture content as milk.

Much cheese is now consumed in the form of processed cheese, e.g., on cheeseburgers. Processed cheese is produced by shredding and melting young natural cheese together with emulsifying salts into a smooth molten mass which is then cooled and moulded into the shape desired. Optional ingredients which may be added during the manufacture of processed cheese include milk powders, casein products, flavours, colours, preservatives and stabilizers. Much processed cheese is sold in the form of blocks or is moulded into large sheets which are then cut into ribbons, interleaved with film, stacked and cut to form convenient slices. Another commercial product is analogue (or imitation cheese). Cheese analogues are cheese-like products formulated from ingredients, usually a form of casein powder known as rennet casein and a source of fat (often butterfat or a vegetable oil); cheese analogues are used mainly as ingredients in consumer-ready meals.

Cheese manufacture. The production of most cheeses falls into two distinct phases: manufacture and ripening. The manufacture of fresh cheese curd generally takes from about five to twenty-four hours; most cheeses are then ripened (matured) to develop the flavour and texture characteristic of the variety.

Cheese manufacture is essentially a dehydration process during which the fat and casein in milk are concentrated between six to twelve-fold, depending on variety. The first operations in the manufacture of cheese curd are the selection and pre-treatment of milk. In industrial practice, milk is usually heated (pasteurised) to kill any disease-causing microorganisms which may be present although some cheese is still made from raw (unpasteurized) milk, usually on a small scale. The ratio of fat to protein in the milk is often adjusted to give the desired composition of the final cheese and, for some varieties colour may be added to the milk.

Cheese is a fermented food product in which the sugar in milk (lactose) is converted to lactic acid by the action of bacteria. The strains of lactic acid bacteria used to acidify milk are usually carefully selected and deliberately added to milk as a culture known as a starter (since it “starts” acid production). Fundamental to cheese manufacture is the removal of moisture from milk through its conversion to a gel followed by contraction of the gel in a process known as syneresis. The milk for some cheeses is gelled by acidification but most the milk for most varieties is coagulated by the enzymes in preparations known as rennets. The gel is cut or broken and the gel pieces contract expressing as whey much of the liquid that was trapped inside. The solid material which will become cheese is known as curd and at this stage of manufacture is suspended in the whey. Syneresis is encouraged by acidification and is often facilitated by heating (“cooking”, “scalding”) the curds/whey mixture. Eventually, the curds are separated from the whey; whey is an important and valuable by-product of cheese manufacture. During the manufacture of most cheeses, the drained curds are then transferred to moulds of a shape and size characteristic of the variety. The curds for high moisture cheeses fuse together under their own weight but those for low moisture varieties are usually pressed to form a continuous mass. However, in the case of Cheddar and related cheeses, curds are “cheddared” before moulding during which they become more acid. The acidified curds for pasta-filata cheeses such as Mozzarella are kneaded and stretched in hot water before moulding.

Salt is added during the manufacture of all cheeses as a preservative and flavouring. Most cheese varieties are salted by immersing the cheese in brine after moulding. However, the curds for Cheddar and related British varieties are cut (“milled”) after cheddaring into small pieces which are then salted using dry salt before being moulded and pressed. Blue cheeses are traditionally salted by rubbing dry salt to the surface of the cheese after it has been moulded.

Cheese ripening. Almost all acid-coagulated and a small amount of rennet-coagulated cheeses are consumed fresh, directly after manufacture. However, the majority of cheese is matured (ripened) for a period ranging from two weeks (e.g., Mozzarella) to two or more years (e.g., Parmigiano-Reggiano or extra-mature Cheddar). It is often difficult to differentiate between the bland flavours and rubbery textures of freshly-made cheeses and it is during ripening that the flavour and texture characteristic of the variety develop. However, the microbiological and biochemical changes which occur during ripening, and hence the flavour and aroma of the finished product, are largely pre-determined by the manufacturing process. Cheese ripening is characterized by a number of microbiological changes and many biochemical changes which are caused by enzymes from the rennet, the milk and from the microorganisms associated with the cheese.

The starter bacteria generally die off after manufacture but they continue to contribute to ripening since their cells burst open after death releasing their enzymes into the cheese. In most long ripened cheeses, wild non-starter lactic acid bacteria grow slowly during ripening and may eventually reach high numbers. However, very obvious microbiological changes occur in certain varieties. The distinctive eyes (holes) in Swiss cheese are caused by the growth of a secondary bacterial flora which converts the lactic acid produced by the starter bacteria to other products, including carbon dioxide gas, some of which is trapped in the cheese to form bubbles. Likewise, the ripening of Blue cheese is dominated by the growth of the mould, Penicillium roqueforti, which develops in fissures within the cheese, giving the blue-green veins typical of these varieties and contributing greatly to their pungent aroma. Another mould, Penicillium camemberti, develops as a felt on the surface of Camembert and Brie where it uses lactic acid, leading to major changes to the texture of these cheeses which often become almost liquid when over-ripe. The most complex microbiological changes occur on the surface of smear-ripened varieties such as Limburger, Tilsit and Münster, where yeasts grow initially and then a mixed bacterial flora develops giving these cheeses their red-orange colour and powerful aroma.

The biochemical changes which occur during ripening involve the conversion of lactic acid, citric acid, milkfat and protein to a very wide range of flavour compounds. Mature cheese contains many hundred flavour compounds and the unique characters of different varieties are caused not by unique chemical compounds but rather by the same compounds but at different levels and in uniquely different proportions. The metabolism of lactic acid is of most importance in Swiss cheese, where is leads to eye development, and in white mould cheeses such as Camembert and Brie, where it leads to softening of the cheese texture. Milk naturally contains a low level of citric acid, some of which is trapped in the curd on cheesemaking and is fermented during the ripening of Dutch-type (e.g., Edam and Gouda) and some other cheeses to flavour compounds and small amounts of carbon dioxide gas which cause the few small eyes typical of these cheeses.

Like all fats, milkfat is composed mainly of a type of molecule known as a triglyceride, which is made of three fatty acids linked to a backbone molecule of glycerol. However, unlike other fats, milkfat is rich in short chain fatty acids which, when liberated from triglycerides by enzyme action (“lipolysis”), are highly flavoured. Low levels of free fatty acids are desirable in most varieties but excessively high levels can cause rancidity. Lipolysis is particularly important in Blue cheeses and in some hard Italian varieties. In addition to their direct impact on flavour, fatty acids also act as precursors of other flavour compounds.

Like all proteins, the caseins which form the structure of cheese are chains of simpler molecules known as amino acids. Protein breakdown (“proteolysis”) is the most important event which occurs during the ripening of most varieties. The caseins are broken down initially by enzymes in the rennet and by the enzyme, plasmin, which occurs naturally in milk, to a range of large and intermediate-sized peptides which are degraded further by enzymes from microorganisms, ultimately to free amino acids. Hard cheeses such as Cheddar contain 200-300 peptides of various sizes produced from the caseins; some smaller fragments contribute to flavours such as bitterness. Free amino acids are precursors for many key flavour compounds which are produced by a very important and complex series of reactions.

Cheese ripening has been the object of considerable scientific research over recent decades. While the general pathways by which most varieties ripen are now known in some detail, it remains impossible to guarantee premium quality cheese; in the midst of science, there remains room for the art of cheesemaking.

CheeseScience.net

Further Information

The Guardian and Cheese Problems...

Courses in Cheese Science

Books